Skip to content
Electricalterminology

Electricalterminology

Best Blog for Basic Electrical Knowledge

Primary Menu
  • Electric
  • Manufacturers & Brands
  • Electronics
  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Affiliate Disclosure
  • Home
  • Electronics
  • Proximity Sensor vs Photoelectric Sensor: Compared Technically!
  • Electronics

Proximity Sensor vs Photoelectric Sensor: Compared Technically!

electricalterminology 2 years ago
What is a proximity sensor

Proximity sensors and photoelectric sensors are widely used in automation applications. But there are some differences between them. Let’s check them one by one.

Differences between proximity sensor and photoelectric sensor

The differences between proximity and photoelectric sensor are the following.

1. Definition

The proximity sensor is a type of device that detects an object when the object approaches the detection range and boundary of the sensor. There is no physical contact between the object and the sensor. Inductive proximity sensors detect only metal objects. Capacitive proximity sensors can sense both metallic and non-metallic objects. The photoelectric sensor is an electrical device that responds to a change in the intensity of the light falling upon it.

2. Method of detection

A proximity sensor uses an electromagnetic field and detects an object without physical contact. Then, converts this information into an electrical signal.

A photoelectric sensor uses light and detects the object without physical contact. The optical signal transmitted from the emitting part of the sensor is modified by being reflected, transmitted, absorbed, etc., by the sensing object and is then detected by the receiving part of the sensor to generate a corresponding output signal.

3. Sensing range

The proximity sensor has a short sensing range compared to the photoelectric sensor. The sensing range of a proximity sensor is within 1 in. (25,44 mm). The sensing range of a photoelectric sensor is up to 800 ft. (243,8 m)

4. Target material

The proximity sensor detects metallic and non-metallic objects. On the other hand, the photoelectric sensor can detect objects of any material provided they affect the optical beam. This means that a photoelectric sensor can be used to detect virtually any object, including glass, plastic, wood, and liquid. (Whether transparent or opaque, small or fast, perforated or shiny, uneven or wrapped in film, near or far.)

5. Response time

The use of an optical beam for detection and complete electronic circuitry makes the photoelectric sensor respond in microseconds so that it can be easily used on a high-speed production line. The response time is extremely fast because light travels at high speed and the sensor performs no mechanical operations because all circuits are comprised of electronic components. The proximity sensor has a little bit longer response time compared to the photoelectric sensor. It detects objects in milliseconds.

6. Object markings

The photoelectric sensor can detect invisible markings on products. The proximity sensor cannot detect the markings.

7. Cost

The average price of a proximity sensor is lower than a photoelectric sensor. The photoelectric sensor has lots of types and various detecting methods. That’s why the average price is expensive.

8. Sensor size

The size of a photoelectric sensor is smaller than a proximity sensor.

9. Color identification

Since the reflection and absorption characteristics vary with the object color for a specified incident optical wavelength, various colors can be detected with a photoelectric sensor as the difference in optical intensity. The proximity sensor cannot identify the colors.

10. Dust and dirt

The photoelectric sensor has the drawback that if the lens surface is covered with dust or dirt and light transmission is obstructed, detection may not be possible. The proximity sensor does not have this problem.

11. Resolution

The incredibly high resolution achieved with the photoelectric sensor derives from advanced design technologies that yielded a very small spot beam and a unique optical system for receiving light. These developments enable the detection of very small objects, as well as precise position detection. The proximity sensor can detect larger objects.

12. Adjustment

Positioning the beam on an object with a photoelectric sensor is simple with models that emit visible light because the beam is visible. The adjustment of a proximity sensor is a bit complex.

Continue Reading

Previous: Advantages and Disadvantages of Solid State Relay
Next: Understanding the Working Principle of a Solid State Relay (SSR)

Related Stories

Advantages of Transducers Advantages of Transducers for Optimal Measurement
  • Electronics

Advantages of Transducers for Optimal Measurement

electricalterminology 2 weeks ago
Advantages of Infrared Sensors Advantages of Infrared Sensors: Improved Accuracy and More
  • Electronics

Advantages of Infrared Sensors: Improved Accuracy and More

electricalterminology 2 weeks ago
VFD Faults Causes Prevention Techniques VFD Faults: Causes and Prevention Techniques
  • Electronics

VFD Faults: Causes and Prevention Techniques

electricalterminology 3 weeks ago
Advantages of PCB Advantages of PCB (Printed Circuit Board) in Electronics
  • Electronics

Advantages of PCB (Printed Circuit Board) in Electronics

electricalterminology 3 weeks ago
Diode Failures Causes Prevention Tips Diode Failures: Causes & Prevention Tips
  • Electronics

Diode Failures: Causes & Prevention Tips

electricalterminology 3 weeks ago
PLC Selection PLC Selection 101: Tips and Tricks for a Successful Choice
  • Electronics

PLC Selection 101: Tips and Tricks for a Successful Choice

electricalterminology 3 weeks ago

Posts List

Advantages of Transducers Advantages of Transducers for Optimal Measurement

Advantages of Transducers for Optimal Measurement

Advantages of Infrared Sensors Advantages of Infrared Sensors: Improved Accuracy and More

Advantages of Infrared Sensors: Improved Accuracy and More

VFD Faults Causes Prevention Techniques VFD Faults: Causes and Prevention Techniques

VFD Faults: Causes and Prevention Techniques

Advantages of PCB Advantages of PCB (Printed Circuit Board) in Electronics

Advantages of PCB (Printed Circuit Board) in Electronics

Diode Failures Causes Prevention Tips Diode Failures: Causes & Prevention Tips

Diode Failures: Causes & Prevention Tips

PLC Selection PLC Selection 101: Tips and Tricks for a Successful Choice

PLC Selection 101: Tips and Tricks for a Successful Choice

Categories

  • Electric
  • Electronics
  • Manufacturers & Brands
  • Uncategorized

Pages

  • About Us
  • Affiliate Disclosure
  • Contact

Recent Posts

  • Essential Guide to Arc Flash Relays and Protection
  • From A to Z: Dual Function Circuit Interrupters
  • Advantages of Transducers for Optimal Measurement
  • Advantages of Infrared Sensors: Improved Accuracy and More
  • Advantages and Disadvantages of Incandescent Lamps
Copyright © All rights reserved. | Magnitude by AF themes.